Lesson 22: Conditions of Performance

In contract law, conditions are specific events or actions that must occur or be performed before a party is obligated to perform under a contract. Understanding the different types of conditions and their implications is essential for analyzing performance and breach of contract issues.

Types of Conditions

Conditions in contracts can be categorized into several types:

  • Conditions Precedent: An event or action that must occur before a party's duty to perform arises.
  • Conditions Subsequent: An event or action that, if it occurs, will discharge a party's duty to perform.
  • Concurrent Conditions: Events or actions that must occur or be performed simultaneously.

Party A's duty to deliver goods is conditioned on Party B's payment of the purchase price.

Conditions Precedent

A condition precedent is an event or state of affairs that must occur before a party is obligated to perform a contractual duty. For example, in a real estate contract, the buyer's obligation to purchase the property may be conditioned on securing financing.

Note: Failure of a condition precedent means the related duty is not activated, and the party is not in breach for non-performance.

Conditions Subsequent

A condition subsequent is an event or state of affairs that, if it occurs, will discharge a party's duty to perform. Unlike a condition precedent, the duty is already in effect, but it will be terminated if the condition is met.

Party A will continue to lease the property unless Party B decides to sell the property.

Concurrent Conditions

Concurrent conditions exist when the parties are to perform their obligations at the same time. An example can be found in the sale of goods, where the buyer's duty to pay is concurrent with the seller's duty to deliver the goods.

graph TD; A["Buyer Payment"] -- "Concurrent Condition" --> B["Seller Delivery"]

Express and Implied Conditions

Conditions can also be categorized as express or implied:

  • Express Conditions: Explicitly stated in the contract.
  • Implied Conditions: Not explicitly stated but inferred from the nature of the contract or the parties' conduct.

The sale is contingent upon the property appraising for at least $500,000.

Legal Implications of Conditions

The fulfillment or breach of conditions has significant legal implications, including:

  • Determining whether a party is obligated to perform.
  • Establishing whether a breach of contract has occurred.
  • Influencing the remedies available in case of a breach.

To explore more about the fundamentals of contracts, see our Definition and Purpose of Contracts and Offer and Acceptance lessons.

Excuse of Conditions

In some cases, conditions may be excused, meaning that a party is relieved from performing the condition. There are several ways in which this can occur:

  • Waiver: A party voluntarily relinquishes the right to enforce the condition.
  • Estoppel: A party is prevented from asserting the condition due to their own actions or representations.
  • Impossibility or Impracticability: Performance of the condition is impossible or impracticable due to unforeseen events.
Important: The excuse of conditions can significantly impact the parties' obligations and rights under the contract.

Waiver

A waiver occurs when a party voluntarily gives up their right to enforce a condition. For example, if a seller agrees to deliver goods without receiving payment in advance, they may be deemed to have waived the condition of pre-payment.

graph TD; A[Condition Exists] -->|Waiver| B[Condition Excused];

Estoppel

Estoppel prevents a party from asserting a condition if their own actions or representations have led the other party to reasonably believe that the condition would not be enforced. For example, if a landlord tells a tenant they need not pay rent on time and the tenant relies on this representation, the landlord may be estopped from later demanding timely payment.

graph TD; A[Party's Representation] --> B[Other Party's Reliance]; B --> C[Estoppel];

Impossibility or Impracticability

If fulfilling a condition becomes impossible or impracticable due to unforeseen events, the condition may be excused. For example, if a contract requires the delivery of goods that are subsequently destroyed in a natural disaster, the condition of delivery may be excused.

graph TD; A[Condition Exists] -->|Impossibility| B[Condition Excused];

Conditions and Breach of Contract

Conditions play a crucial role in determining whether a breach of contract has occurred:

  • If a condition precedent is not met, a party's duty to perform is not triggered, and there is no breach.
  • If a condition subsequent occurs, the duty to perform is discharged, and future performance is not required.
  • If concurrent conditions are not fulfilled by both parties, neither party may claim breach against the other.

Case Study

Let's explore a hypothetical scenario to understand the practical implications of conditions in a contract:

Company A agrees to purchase raw materials from Company B under the condition that Company A secures a contract from a third-party buyer. If Company A fails to secure the contract, it is not obligated to purchase the raw materials, and Company B cannot claim breach of contract.

Conclusion

Understanding the various types of conditions and their legal implications is essential for navigating contract performance and breach issues. Conditions determine the obligations and rights of parties, excusing performance in some cases and establishing grounds for breach in others.

For more advanced topics on contracts, explore our lessons on Substantial Performance and Material Breach vs. Minor Breach.

Next »