Lesson 29: Nominal Damages

Introduction

In contract law, remedies for breach of contract serve to put the injured party in a position as close as possible to the one they would have been in had the breach not occurred. Among these remedies are nominal damages, which are awarded when a breach has occurred, but the non-breaching party has not suffered a quantifiable financial loss.

Nominal damages are a token sum awarded to recognize that a breach of contract has occurred, even if no real monetary loss is proven.

Purpose of Nominal Damages

The primary purpose of nominal damages is to acknowledge a legal wrong. Essentially, they serve the following functions:

  • To affirm the existence of the plaintiff's rights.
  • To mark the breach of contract.
  • To potentially serve as a basis for awarding court costs or attorney fees.

When Are Nominal Damages Awarded?

Nominal damages are awarded in situations where:

  • The plaintiff has proven that a breach occurred.
  • The plaintiff has not proven any actual financial loss resulting from the breach.

For example, if an individual contracts to purchase a rare book for $500, and the seller breaches the contract by selling the book to someone else but the buyer cannot find a replacement or suffer any financial harm, nominal damages may still be awarded. Check out rare books on Amazon.

Legal Significance of Nominal Damages

While the monetary value of nominal damages is typically small, their legal significance can be considerable. Nominal damages serve to affirm that the defendant's conduct was legally wrong. This affirmation can be important for several reasons:

  • It helps uphold contractual obligations.
  • It establishes a precedent, which can influence future cases.
  • It can be used to vindicate the plaintiff's legal rights.
graph TD A["Plaintiff proves breach"] --> B["No financial loss proven"] B --> C["Nominal damages awarded"]

In some jurisdictions, the award of nominal damages can also serve as a basis for awarding attorney's fees or court costs to the prevailing party.

Examples of Nominal Damages

To better understand nominal damages, consider the following examples:

  • Example 1: A musician signs a contract to perform at a concert but the concert is canceled. The musician did not incur any financial loss because another performance was scheduled for the same date, but nominal damages may still be awarded for the breach of contract.
  • Example 2: A homeowner contracts a painter to paint their house. The painter finishes the job a day late but the homeowner was not financially harmed. Nominal damages can be awarded to acknowledge the breach.

Nominal Damages vs. Other Damages

It's important to differentiate nominal damages from other types of damages:

Case Law and Nominal Damages

Several legal cases highlight the application of nominal damages:

  • Ashby v. White (1703): A landmark case where the court recognized the right to vote as a legal right worth protecting, even without substantial damage.
  • Marbury v. Madison (1803): Although nominal damages were not awarded, the case established the important principle of judicial review, underscoring that legal wrongs need recognition.

Conclusion

Nominal damages play a crucial role in contract law by acknowledging breaches even when no financial loss occurs. This serves to uphold the integrity of contractual agreements and ensure that legal rights are recognized. Understanding nominal damages helps in appreciating the broader spectrum of remedies available for breach of contract and the importance of legal recognition of wrongs.

« Previous
Next »