Lesson 44: Client Competency

Part of Ethical Considerations in Advanced Estate Planning

Understanding client competency is crucial in advanced estate planning. Competency or capacity refers to a person's mental ability to understand the nature and effects of their actions. This is essential for the validity of legal documents and decisions in estate planning.

Check out these books on Amazon for more in-depth information on estate planning.

Legal Definition of Competency

Competency is a legal determination that involves assessing a person's ability to make informed decisions. This is governed by both statutory and case law. In estate planning, competency typically pertains to the mental capacity required to execute wills, trusts, and other legal instruments.

Note: The standard for determining competency can vary based on the jurisdiction and the specific legal act in question.

Types of Competency

Testamentary Capacity: The mental capability required to create a valid will. A person must understand the nature of the act, the extent of their property, and the natural objects of their bounty.
Contractual Capacity: The ability to understand and engage in contractual agreements, such as establishing trusts or executing powers of attorney.

The assessment of these competencies often involves evaluating a client's cognitive function and understanding of relevant matters.

Test Process for Competency

The process to determine competency can include:

Medical evaluations and psychological assessments
Interviews with the client and their family members
Review of relevant medical and legal documents

graph LR A[Client exhibits questionable behavior] --> B[Initiate competency evaluation] B --> C[Medical and psychological assessments] B --> D[Interviews with family] B --> E[Review of documents] C --> F[Assessment Report] D --> F E --> F F --> G[Legal Determination of Competency]

Once an assessment is complete, the findings are compiled into a report, which is then used to make a legal determination of the client's competency.

Legal Implications of Incompetency

If a client is deemed incompetent, various legal consequences follow:

Void or Voidable Documents: Legal documents executed by an incompetent person may be void or subject to being voided.
Appointment of Guardians: Courts may appoint a guardian or conservator to make decisions on behalf of the incompetent individual.
Revocation of Powers of Attorney: Existing powers of attorney may be revoked, and new ones may not be created by the incompetent individual.

Guardianship Process

The guardianship process typically involves:

Filing a petition for guardianship in court
Notification of interested parties
Hearing and presentation of evidence
Appointment of the guardian by the court

graph TD A[Petition for Guardianship] --> B[Notification of interested parties] B --> C[Court Hearing] C --> D[Presentation of Evidence] D --> E[Court Appointment of Guardian]

The appointment of a guardian involves careful judicial scrutiny to ensure it is in the best interest of the incompetent person.

Ethical Obligations When Assessing Competency

Attorneys have ethical obligations when assessing client competency. These duties include:

Duty of Care: The attorney must take reasonable steps to determine the client's competency.
Duty of Confidentiality: Client information must be kept confidential, even when assessing competency.
Duty to Act in Client's Best Interest: Attorneys must always act in the best interest of the client, which may involve seeking medical evaluations or third-party consultations.

Steps to Ensure Ethical Compliance

To ensure ethical compliance, attorneys can follow these steps:

Conduct preliminary assessments during initial consultations.
Seek medical or psychological evaluations if competency is in question.
Document all findings and maintain confidentiality.
Consult with other professionals, such as social workers or medical practitioners, when necessary.

graph TD A[Initial Consultation] --> B[Preliminary Assessment] B --> C[Seek Medical/Psychological Evaluation] C --> D[Document Findings] D --> E[Maintain Confidentiality] A --> F[Consult with Professionals]

Case Studies and Examples

Examining case studies can provide valuable insights into handling competency issues. Below are a few examples:

Case Study 1: Incompetency and Will Contest

A client, John, exhibited signs of dementia but insisted on modifying his will. His attorney conducted a competency evaluation, which revealed John lacked testamentary capacity. Later, John's relatives contested the will, citing his incompetency. The court voided the modifications based on the attorney's thorough documentation.

sequenceDiagram participant Attorney participant John participant Court Attorney->>John: Conducts competency evaluation John-->>Attorney: Displays signs of dementia Attorney->>Court: Submits evaluation report Court-->>Attorney: Voids will modifications due to incompetency

Case Study 2: Guardianship Appointment

Mary, an elderly client, was unable to manage her affairs. Her attorney noticed cognitive decline and recommended a guardianship. The attorney filed a petition, and after a court hearing, Mary's son was appointed as her guardian.

sequenceDiagram participant Attorney participant Mary participant Court participant Son Attorney->>Court: Files guardianship petition Court->>Mary: Holds hearing Court->>Son: Appoints guardian

Practical Tips for Practitioners

Practitioners can follow these tips to effectively manage client competency issues:

Regular Training: Stay updated on legal standards and best practices through continuing education and training.
Interdisciplinary Approach: Collaborate with medical professionals to obtain comprehensive assessments.
Clear Communication: Use plain language and ensure clients fully understand the issues at hand.
Documentation: Keep detailed records of all assessments and communications to protect client interests and guard against future disputes.

Conclusion

Ensuring client competency is a critical aspect of ethical estate planning. Attorneys must employ thorough assessment processes, understand the legal implications of incompetency, and adhere to ethical obligations to protect their clients' interests. By following best practices and learning from real-world examples, practitioners can navigate these challenges effectively.

For further reading on related topics, you might be interested in: